What Ornellaia’s Charity Auction Does and Doesn’t Tell You

Ornellaia has just wrapped its annual Vendemmia d'Artista charity auction — the 18th edition — and the numbers look eye-catching. Fourteen lots, all sold, just under £110,000 raised for the Guggenheim Foundation in New York.

Home » What Ornellaia’s Charity Auction Does and Doesn’t Tell You

Record-looking prices at a wine charity sale are easy to misread. Here’s the difference between a collectible and an investment — and why it matters before you buy.

Ornellaia has just wrapped its annual Vendemmia d’Artista charity auction — the 18th edition — and the numbers look eye-catching. Fourteen lots, all sold, just under £110,000 raised for the Guggenheim Foundation in New York. The top lot, a one-off nine-litre Salmanazar of the 2023 signed by the artist Marina Abramović — topped with a wax candle and paired with a Nino Rota vinyl record and a dinner for six at the estate — went for around £20,000, against an estimate of roughly £17,000 to £34,000. A twelve-bottle case holding the full run of artist labels from 2012 to 2023 made about £11,700, well over its top estimate.

It’s a lovely story, and a clever one. Since 2009, Ornellaia has had a contemporary artist interpret each vintage’s character, then sold the results for charity. It burnishes the brand and does genuine good. What it is not is a signal about what Ornellaia is worth as an investment — and it’s worth being clear about why, because these headlines get misread all the time.

Look at what actually sold. A unique bottle signed by a famous artist. A bottle with a candle on it and a record to play while you drink it. A case bundled with a private dinner. These are collectibles and experiences, and the prices reflect the artist, the uniqueness, the evening at the estate and the fact that the money goes to a good cause. They don’t reflect the market value of the wine in the bottle. You cannot buy ten more of that Salmanazar, you cannot sell it on tomorrow at a known price, and the next person’s willingness to pay has as much to do with Abramović and philanthropy as with the 2023 vintage. That’s the opposite of what makes something an investment.

This is the distinction that matters, and it’s one a lot of buyers blur: a collectible is a one-off you own because you want it; an investment is a liquid, benchmarked thing you own because you can value it and sell it. A signed art bottle is the former. A standard case of a tradeable wine, priced against the market every day, is the latter. Charity results tell you about the first category. They tell you nothing useful about the second.

Which is a shame, because the real Ornellaia question is a more interesting one than “look what a candle-topped bottle fetched.” Ornellaia sits among the Super Tuscans — the Bolgheri and Tuscan names that have earned a proper place in serious collections over the last decade, alongside rather than beneath Bordeaux and Burgundy. As a category it has offered relative value and better availability than the First Growths, and it has broadened where fine wine money sensibly goes. That’s the conversation worth having about Ornellaia: where it fits, which vintages, at what level, and how it sits next to its stablemate Masseto and the rest of the Super Tuscan pack.

So enjoy the art bottles for exactly what they are — a smart bit of theatre for a good cause. Just don’t file the auction result under “market intelligence.” If you want to know whether Ornellaia belongs in your portfolio, that’s a better question than any headline from a charity sale can answer, and it’s one we’re happy to get into properly.

Fine wine is a long-term, illiquid asset and can fall as well as rise. Nothing here is financial advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any particular wine.

If you would like to see how a transparent, considered approach to fine wine investment actually works, you can read about our investment basics or get in touch with our London team for a straightforward conversation.

More Fine Wine Investment News

Find out more about what is happening now in the world of fine wine investment.

What our clients say

Why Fine Wine investment?

Fine wine investment has a proven track record of providing safe and reliable returns even in the harshest of economic climates.

Due to its relative stability in comparison to the volatile equity markets, most investors choose to hold their investment wines for medium to long term periods to achieve the optimum return.

Single continuous line drawing of 3 people cheersing wine glasses.
Single continuous line drawing of a hand hold up a bar chart.

Proven track record

Fine wine investment has a proven track record of providing safe and reliable returns even in the harshest of economic climates.

Single continuous line drawing of a woman holding a giant key up to a giant lock.

Secure physical asset

Investors in fine wine own their assets outright in government-regulated bond and have the investment insure against all potential risks to the wine.

Single continuous black line drawing of a thumbs up.

Exempt from VAT

Also – If managed correctly, fine wine investment should in most cases be free from capital gains tax too.

Download our free Fine Wine Investment Guide

Fill in your details below and we’ll send you a copy of our fine wine investment guide.